I’ve made a complete lot of The Pasta Queen’s recipes (from her Snappy Harlot to her Satan’s Kiss), they usually have by no means led me astray, so I had excessive expectations when it got here time to present her pasta carbonara a spin in our Movie star Recipe Showdown. When choosing opponents for the showdown, I knew there needed to be some illustration from somebody who knew conventional Italian cooking inside and outside, and I can’t consider a greater particular person than Nadia, my go-to pasta knowledgeable on TikTok. Right here’s the way it all went.

Get the recipe: The Pasta Queen’s Spaghetti Carbonara

The best way to Make The Pasta Queen’s Spaghetti Carbonara

At its core, carbonara is a straightforward dish with just a few substances. Nadia’s carbonara is as conventional because it will get. She requires guanciale and pecorino Romano cheese, that are generally swapped for bacon or pancetta and Parmesan cheese in much less conventional variations of the dish. To start out, prepare dinner your pasta (spaghetti or rigatoni) till al dente, reserve some pasta water, and drain.

In the meantime, prepare dinner the diced guanciale in a big skillet till the fats renders and the meat is golden-brown and crispy. In a bowl, whisk eggs, grated cheese, and black pepper. Over low warmth, toss the pasta with the guanciale to mix. Subsequent, take away the pan from warmth and blend within the egg and cheese combination, working swiftly to stop the eggs from scrambling and progressively drizzling in pasta water as wanted. Season to style with extra pepper or cheese, then twirl into bowls and serve instantly. For an genuine Pasta Queen expertise, exclaim “Simply beautiful!” as you set the bowls of pasta on the desk.

My Trustworthy Evaluation of The Pasta Queen’s Spaghetti Carbonara

This was divine. Though carbonara requires just a few substances and is comparatively fast to make, I’ll admit that it does require a little bit of follow and finesse to actually get it proper. This methodology was fully profitable. My closing sauce was so wealthy and creamy that it tasted like there was butter or cream in it (however true to Italian custom, these substances had been fully absent).

Though she affords pancetta in its place, I actually needed to attempt guanciale to see if it made a distinction. This did require a visit to my native Italian deli (shout out to Bay Cities) and it was admittedly costlier than pancetta. I’ll say that it rendered extra fats than any reduce of meat that I’ve ever cooked, which positively contributed to the wealthy, salty sauce. It additionally had an unmistakable porky taste that was saltier and fattier than pancetta. Was it life-changing? I don’t suppose so, and if you wish to sub pancetta, I don’t suppose the standard of your carbonara will undergo (however perhaps don’t inform Nadia I stated that).

I used to be additionally excited to do that one out as a result of it was the one recipe of 4 contenders that referred to as completely for pecorino Romano. The distinction was refined. To me, pecorino Romano is barely saltier and tangier than Parm, and I felt the outcomes yielded simply that. I didn’t discover it overwhelmingly higher than Parm, simply completely different. 

There was some slight confusion with the recipe as a result of her substances name for eggs, however the methodology requires egg yolks. I referenced this video of hers, the place she says that she makes use of 1 egg yolk per serving, plus 1 further complete egg. So, I took this to imply that for 1 pound of pasta, she makes use of 4 egg yolks and 1 complete egg. In that very same video, she additionally mentions that she likes to mood the egg combination with somewhat little bit of the rendered pork fats, so I did that as effectively, which eased my fears about doubtlessly scrambling the eggs.

I wouldn’t have a drop of Italian blood in me, however after I made this, I began to marvel if perhaps I do have a pair ancestors in Florence or Rome as a result of this was scrumptious.

If You’re Making The Pasta Queen’s Spaghetti Carbonara, a Few Ideas

Sara Tane


Sara Tane is a meals author and personal chef based mostly in Los Angeles, CA (together with her canine, Pepper). She is a graduate of the Institute of Culinary Training and has written for Food52, Good Housekeeping, Cooking Gentle, and AllRecipes. She additionally has a critical factor for oysters.



Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here